I would recommend the Inn of Last Resort, this is our 4th trip to the "Inn" and we are already booked for a 5th trip. The food is very good (my wife loves that alot of the meals have fresh soup). The diving and boats were great, the boats are not the fastest but I prefer the extra 2 minutes it takes to get to the dive sites. You get more time to chat with everyone and just relax taking in the view. There is no rush rush cattle call feeling at the Inn, its very easy going and friendly. The Inn is a small enough dive resort where you can literally be on a first name basis with every guest and employee in less than a week.